215 Sycamore AvenueNew Construction Home in Anna Maria, FL
Anna Maria, FL 34216 · Manatee County
$5,895,000
$1814/sq ft
Photos of 215 Sycamore Avenue
1 / 30About this home
Welcome to a rare offering on the coveted north end of Anna Maria Island — a brand-new coastal sanctuary where architectural sophistication meets the timeless charm of Old Florida. Ideally positioned just steps from the sugar-white sands of the Gulf and moments from the boutique shops, galleries, and countless dining options of historic Pine Avenue and the surrounding area, this exceptional 4-bedroom, 4.5-bath residence captures the essence of elevated island living — and sits within one of the island’s most desirable short-term rental zones. Designed with a refined, light-filled aesthetic, the home welcomes you with wide-plank hardwood flooring and a seamless flow between spaces that feel at once elegant and effortless. At the heart of the main level, a designer kitchen serves as the showpiece — outfitted with custom cabinetry, a generous island with seating, premium appliances, a dedicated wet bar, and a fully appointed butler’s pantry that makes entertaining feel second nature. Multiple gathering areas, including a secondary upstairs family room, offer a thoughtful balance of togetherness and retreat. The primary suite is a private sanctuary of understated luxury, anchored by a spa-inspired bath with a sculptural soaking tub, oversized walk-in shower, and bespoke designer finishes. Three of the four bedrooms enjoy their own private ensuites, and every bedroom features a walk-in closet — a refined blend of privacy and comfort for family and guests alike. Step outside to a fully screened ground-level living area that functions as a true extension of the home, complete grilling area and lounge designed for year-round enjoyment. Beyond, a private tropical oasis unfolds around a sparkling pool with integrated spa and a gas firepit framed by lush landscaping and a vinyl privacy fence that creates a secluded, resort-caliber setting for gathering or quiet escape. Every detail has been considered for ease and longevity, including Lutron lighting controls, three-zone climate systems, a metal roof, outdoor shower, and a three-car garage. Offered fully furnished, the property is delivered as a true move in ready opportunity. Beyond the walls of the home lies the magic of the north end — the most coveted and character-rich stretch of Anna Maria Island, known for its pristine beaches, the legendary white sands of Bean Point where the Gulf meets Tampa Bay and the walkable, tree-lined corridor of Pine Avenue with its celebrated restaurants, cottage shops, and cafés. Days begin with sunrise strolls along the shore and end with sunset dinners just minutes from your front door. With short-term rentals permitted, unmatched walkability to both the beach and Pine Avenue, and a rare combination of design, location, and lifestyle, this residence represents one of the most compelling offerings on Anna Maria Island — a legacy property with exceptional income potential in Florida’s most storied coastal village.
Home details and costs
- MLS number
- A4689780
- Property type
- Single Family Residence
- Build stage
- Move-In Ready
- Heated square feet
- 3,250 sq ft
- Total under roof
- 6,025 sq ft
- Stories
- 2 Story
- Lot size
- 0.19 acres
- Subdivision
- Anna Maria Beach
- HOA fee
- No HOA
- Annual property tax
- $14,220 (current assessment)
- Days on market
- 184 days
Heads up on that tax figure. On new construction, the number in the MLS is often the tax on the bare lot, not the finished home. Expect it to jump once the county reassesses with the house on it. How Florida reassesses new builds
What would this home actually cost per month?
Pre-filled with this listing's price and HOA. Adjust anything to match your situation.
Estimated monthly payment
$44,779
$589,500 down (10%) on a $5,305,500 loan
- Principal and interest
- $33,534
- Property tax (estimated)
- $8,768
- Homeowners insurance
- $267
- PMI (under 20% down)
- $2,211
CDD defaults to zero, and that is often wrong.Many Tampa Bay new-construction communities carry a Community Development District assessment of roughly $1,500 to $3,000 a year on top of HOA, and it is rarely included in a builder's payment estimate. Ask whether this address is in a CDD before you budget.
The tax figure in the MLS looks like a bare-lot assessment. It lists $14,220 a year, while taxing this purchase price works out closer to $105,210. On new construction the county reassesses once the house is finished, so budget from the higher number.
Estimates only. Actual taxes, insurance, and assessments vary by address and change year to year.
Get the real numbers on this homeWhat is negotiable on this home?
This listing shows real leverage signals. Here is what its own numbers say.
On the market 184 daysStrong signal
Past six months on a finished home means the builder has been carrying taxes, insurance, and interest on it the whole time. That cost is real and it is why concessions get easier the longer a home sits.
Finished and standingWorth knowing
A completed home with a Certificate of Occupancy is inventory, not a future sale. Builders treat standing inventory very differently from a lot they have not broken ground on.
Where builders actually give
Rarely on the published base price. It sets the comp for every unsold home behind this one, and protecting it protects their appraisals. The real room is in closing cost credits, interest rate buydowns, and upgrades moved into the base. Asking for the right one in the right order is most of the job.
Other new construction homes in Anna Maria
Move-In Ready90$6,995,000
$1711/sq ft242 Lakeview Drive
Anna Maria, FL 34216 · Lake La Vista Rep
MLS #A4704981 · Sato Real Estate Inc.
Move-In Ready74$5,495,000
$1686/sq ft411 Palm Avenue
Anna Maria, FL 34216 · Bimini Bay Estates
Eason Builders Group
MLS #A4698723 · Re/max Alliance Group
Listed by Duncan Real Estate, Inc.. Listing data provided courtesy of Stellar MLS via Bridge Interactive. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. 215 Sycamore Avenue, Anna Maria, FL 34216 is presented by Barrett Henry, REMAX Collective. Prices, availability, and incentives change without notice.